Skip to content
I drink and watch anime
Menu
  • Guest Posting
  • Reviews
  • Essays
  • Lists
  • Character studies
  • Conversion Chart
  • Contact
Menu

The Positive Negative Review

Posted on July 8, 2023June 30, 2023 by Irina

I am one of the three people out there that openly admits to being a fan of ranty or negative reviews. Most bloggers hold back from writing overly negative posts and the general consensus I’ve seen from people in the anime community is that if you don’t have anything nice to say, don’t say anything at all. I’ve long believe this to be a rather limiting point of vue. I’m more of the if you don’t have anything nice to say, come sit next to me” school of thought. Lately however, I think I’ve started to understand why.

It seems that negative reviews aren’t simply a single entity that can be lumped together. They are in fact several subspecies with very different characteristics and impacts. I think this is what explains the varying views regarding these posts and not that I am a bitter troll that feeds on mankind’s worst impulses…not only that.

troll
ok it’s mostly that

As far as I can tell, there are essentially 4 ways to discuss a series you did not personally enjoy.

First we have the professional way. The one that tends to be favoured by the most prolific bloggers that cannot realistically manage furious rants every day. It is framed as a generally impartial informative posts. I.e. I did not enjoy the anime and these are the reasons why. These are the objective and technical failings and these are my subjective takeaways and so on. At this point, you can’t even really call it negative so much as descriptive. Let’s face it, some anime is just bad. We are going to have to accept that some day.

The second way is the gold star, everyone is a winner way. These are posts that try to create a compliment sandwich. Bloggers that tell you they did not like a show then go out of their way to emphasize the things that still worked. These are the sweetest folks and you wish you could be friends with hem in real life because they would probably always support you and find a bright side. I can understand why this approach is popular. It certainly leaves you feeling more cheerful and optimistic. However, it has also tricked me into watching a lot of not so great shows. Awww, who am I kidding? I would have watched them anyways. I’m one of those dumb kids that had to touch the stove.

Then there are my personal favourite ones the snarky, sarcastic good humoured rants. These posts don’t pull any punches but you also never get the impression that the author is angry at the show for having had to watch it. More often than not these are humoristic takes on a bad series poking fun at everything that went wrong. The trick here, is the same as in a good roast. The post can be biting and even harsh but it has to remain fun and never mean. There’s an art to it. Listening to (reading) someone whining for minutes on end is completely unappealing. Seeing them gratuitously insult something is uncomfortable and wears thin very quickly. However, well thrown shade with just enough truth in it to be justified is a work of art. One that we don’t come across often enough.

anime shades
not shadeS…oh nevermind

After all, we improve by learning from mistakes. Whether our own or others’. As such, pointing out those mistakes can be helpful to all. But it needs to be done right. Which brings me to:

The rage rant. The name probably makes you think of those incoherent all caps assaults you occasionally see particularly passionate fans throw out. But I would argue that the worst of these are those that cover up the vitriol with pompous vocabulary or pseudo reasoning. Like I just did in that last sentence. You know those posts that just seem utterly joyless. The ones that don’t limit themselves at saying, this show was bad, as in the examples above, but actually push the narrative all the way to this show was bad and if you enjoyed it, there’s something wrong with you.

Despite my most ardent efforts at burying my head in the sand, I’ve been seeing these types of “reviews” pop up quite a bit over the past year. Less in the blogging community thankfully. They imply either a lack of moral character, knowledge or intelligence in the fans of certain series. If you enjoyed this you must be “x”. Or it’s because of shows like this that x happens. Where “x” is always an objectively bad impact on anime as a whole and the implication is that a show’s following is therefore responsible.

I’m dumbing it down of course, most bloggers will not be so direct. But still, if you ever came away from a post feeling embarrassed about liking a show, then on some level the author must have insinuated that you should be. The thing is, if you happen to agree with the author’s assessment of the series, these posts are powerful confirmation bias which will most likely earn a certain degree of devotion from readers.

chuunibiyou
I’m not embarrassed, YOU’re embarrassed

I believe this latest form of posts is what people mostly think of when they hear “negative review”. It should also be noted that some people (lots of people including occasionally me) do get very protective of beloved anime and can feel attacked even if the post is fairly neutral or respectful. And when I take that into consideration, I can easily understand why someone would rather avoid that particular type of criticism. I will still put up with it if I think it’s funny though. Cause you know… troll and all that…

So I’ve decided to slightly modify my stance on negative reviews. I still think it’s not only o.k. but important to voice differing opinions and constructive criticism. I even encourage you to go on good old rants when warranted. It will make you feel better! But, please don’t turn your ire against the fans of a series. Once it gets personal, it’s not a joke anymore, it’s bullying. Man that sounds dramatic. OK so it’s not really bullying but it’s pointless and no fun.

Of course, I just wrote all this for absolutely nothing. None of my readers are the type to attack others but hey. Maybe somebody who this applies to will accidently click on it while trying to read the post above…

anime bored
and tab closed!

Share this - be my hero:

  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit

Like this:

Like Loading…

Related

11 thoughts on “The Positive Negative Review”

  1. stillcircle says:
    July 15, 2023 at 7:35 am

    Frankly, if I so disliked an anime so much that I felt I was doing to angrily rant about it, I would probably just stop watching it…

    Loading...
    Reply
  2. Mari says:
    July 14, 2023 at 6:44 pm

    I have written a couple negative reviews in the past, but I prefer to focus on series that had a lot of potential and failed to follow through. Maybe the show had a solid start but crapped out on the ending, or there were production issues, or it’s an adaptation that deviates wildly from the source material. I feel that gives more nuance to the discussion and makes for a more interesting read overall. Like, no one needs to read another post about why “generic seasonal isekai #56” is bad. We already know 😛

    Loading...
    Reply
  3. K at the Movies says:
    July 8, 2023 at 10:28 pm

    🙂

    Loading...
    Reply
  4. Paul Kemner says:
    July 8, 2023 at 2:58 pm

    The only time I can see myself writing a negative review is of a good series that trashed itself with a stupid ending. If in Madoka Magica she woke up and it was all a dream, instead of her short-circuiting the whole setup.
    There are so many shows on my to-watch list that I’m going to drop a series i don’t like immediately, unless someone convinces me otherwise and I come back to it.

    Loading...
    Reply
    1. Irina says:
      July 12, 2023 at 8:57 pm

      You know that is a healthy attitude 😊

      Loading...
      Reply
  5. Tanish Shrivastava says:
    July 8, 2023 at 2:40 pm

    Message received.

    Though I can only do these reviews when I watch more anime, instead of being restricted to the dub. I do hope my Japanese skills will be up to the par for this, as I do hope to be able to watch some anime in Japanese, starting with Shin-Chan. Why not? A Japanese person has already confirmed for me that it does not use any difficult Japanese, so it will be a perfect test for me.

    Then Kochikame. Then Bakabon. Then all those anime which never received a dub because “It will not be liked by the audience, it will confuse the audience, or got butchered into unrecognizable mess, like Detective Conan.”

    Once that happens, you can expect to read rants from me.

    Loading...
    Reply
    1. Irina says:
      July 12, 2023 at 9:01 pm

      Oh I’m looking forward to it 😁

      Loading...
      Reply
  6. terranceacrow says:
    July 8, 2023 at 1:50 pm

    “OK so it’s not really bullying but it’s pointless and no fun.”

    I think you might have been right the first time — at least, it sure looks like an attempt at bullying. That’s why some of those folks get all bombastic: it’s an attempt to establish a rhetorically superior position. It’s in line with broader “developments” in online discourse I’ve watched over the last several years.

    Particularly hilarious to me are reviewers who try to say something is “objectively” bad and that they’re the one who’s in an intellectual and cultural position to say so. Just wow.

    I like how you divided this type of review into subspecies. I wouldn’t mind reading more clever roast rants. They’re few and far between, and I understand why. They’re tough to pull off. They require a lot of experience within a topic and a sense of what the community knows. Otherwise, the references can fall flat. I’ll bet you could pull it off — and apologies if you already have an I’ve forgotten. My short term memory is not on speaking terms with me right now, given the amount of work I’m trying to shovel through!

    Loading...
    Reply
    1. Irina says:
      July 12, 2023 at 9:11 pm

      Intellectual and cultural position to say so…. I’m not sure I could ever drink enough to say something like that and mean it. My liver wouldn’t forgive me that’s for sure

      Loading...
      Reply
  7. Kenrin says:
    July 8, 2023 at 1:34 pm

    I don’t think anime should be treated differently than movies or video games. This ‘never express anything negative’ mindset was always weird to me. Negative criticism is just as, or even more important than positive imo. You might save someone’s time if their taste resembles yours. I feel like being overly positive and giving out 10/10s to everything simply diminishes the value of one’s opinion.
    Also, imo writing about bad things is the most fun. It’s difficult to come up with new superlatives to praise something you loved, and assessing something painfully mediocre might be an even bigger challenge. Bad things, however, are very easy to dissect and they allow for more creativity.
    I’m also against mindless rambling, simply calling something bad does not provide any value to the reader, writings like that have to be substantial. But the general sentiment against negative reviews in the anime community is kind of perplexing to me. For instance, a few days ago on a forum, I said I don’t like a certain character and a person completely freaked out that I’m stopping others from enjoying the story?? Like wtf, just form your own opinions, the purpose of a review isn’t telling you exactly what to think, but to give you a certain viewpoint that might or might not align with yours.
    Again, I’m not saying that angry drivel written in a deliberately baity and provocative manner should be supported in any way, but shaming others because they didn’t like something is just as bad as doing the opposite.

    Loading...
    Reply
    1. Irina says:
      July 12, 2023 at 9:14 pm

      Oh I agree! Anime is a medium
      A very broad and rich one. There is no way you’re not going to trip on some subpar series at some point

      Loading...
      Reply

Leave me a comment and make my day! Cancel reply

find me here

  • X
  • Pinterest
  • Facebook
Irina

Irina

Hi! My name is Irina and I think we should be friends. So come on in, make yourself comfortable, grab a drink, there's juice also, and let's chat about anime!

View Full Profile →

You Know you want to

Join 3,679 other subscribers

Top Five Voice Actors in My Harem

Top 5 Pleasant End of the World Animes

Guest Posting

Uta no Prince Sama Legend Star -or- Heavens and Heck

Getting Ready to Sue – Top 5 Anime Characters That Are Clearly Based on Me

And just like that, I love Mondays

Follow up on Writing Blog Comments

To Your Eternity 2 ep. 3- Friends

Gahkthun of the Golden Lightning – Putting the Novel Back in Visual Novel

Outburst Dreamer Boys – The Dangers of Judging Books by Covers

Follow I drink and watch anime on WordPress.com

Archives

Tags

action adventure anime Bad idea blogin' blonde bishie Bungo Stray Dogs challenge Collab comedy Demon Slayer: Kimetsu No Yaiba Dr. Stone drama episodic Essays fanservice Fantasy Fire Force found family historical Horror Irina learned nothing Irina pretends to know things isekai List Lists Magical manga mecha moe music Mystery psychological romance School science! sci fi screencaps shonen slice of life Sports! Steins;Gate supernatural super powers surreal thriller urban fantasy Yaoi yokai yummy

Recent Comments

Otakuen on Top 5 Anime Gadgets
Brock on Most Popular Anime by Year of…
voxalike on Undead Girl Murder Farce – Wha…
animeflv on Guest Posting
ivorylane@gmail.com on ‘Tis Time for “Tor…
Animesuge on Guest Posting
Abgh guofg on Guest Posting
Agghhh hhh on Guest Posting

little things that make me happy

  • 2,228,978 hugs

Recent Comments

Otakuen on Top 5 Anime Gadgets
Brock on Most Popular Anime by Year of…
voxalike on Undead Girl Murder Farce – Wha…
animeflv on Guest Posting
ivorylane@gmail.com on ‘Tis Time for “Tor…

Blog Stats

  • 2,228,978 hits

If you read all the way down here, you rock!

© 2026 I drink and watch anime | Powered by Superbs Personal Blog theme
Loading Comments...
%d