Erased – Future Past

Image result for erased anime

  • Genre : Time travel, Murder mystery, Grade school action
  • Episodes: 12
  • Studio: A-1 Pictures

 

Satoru is in his late 20s and works at a pizzeria. He is stoic, jaded and disconnected from pretty much everything. He is also definitely not a pedophile. He is just aimlessly drifting through life when his boring little world gets suddenly turned upside down. After getting hit by a car he transforms into Sam Beckett, only not really cause he can only revert back into himself, and realizes he has the chance to set right what once went wrong. Also there’s a psycho child killer.

This is a rewrite of one of my first anime reviews. Not that many people got to see it and honestly, I didn’t think I did the series justice the first time around. I wrote this review very shortly after finishing Erased back in 2017 and I did like the series at the time. However, as the years rolled on, I find myself thinking back to this show way more than I thought I would and have started to think of it much more fondly. This is why I thought it would be amusing to see what I wrote back then and update it. Also, I have been working ridiculous hours and haven’t had the chance to finish any new series in a while…. But the main reason is the update and rethink thing…yeah, that’s it!

I don’t actually have many friends who like anime (I do have friends, shut up) and as such I often feel a little disconnected from the anime community and sometimes, I have a skewed perspective on a show’s reputation. From a distance though, Erased seems pretty divisive. Reviewers and fans alike all seem to have individual opinions and a general agreement has yet to be reached. I could be wrong. In any case, liked it.

I’m a little confused about why I wrote this. A few years down the line and my impression is that Erased was generally well received by all. Aside from a few specific criticisms about certain elements, it seems most people did enjoy it as a whole. Or maybe I just remember that I did and everything else pouffed.   

Erased Review intro

Yay – we get to watch anime!

I’m a sucker for a time travel story but they tend to be almost unavoidably messy. Once you start getting into grandfather paradoxes and butterfly effects it takes a masterfully crafted narrative to hold everything together. Erased doesn’t handle it perfectly but it does a pretty good job. By keeping the story fairly restrained, concentrating on a single major event and its ramification on a fairly small group of friends, it manages to avoid a lot of the common pitfalls of the genre and doesn’t make your brain bleed too much. The time jumping also allows us to get to know the characters at different times in their lives. I love when the after-credit scenes show us what happened after the store and this show seemed to weave those types of scenes throughout the actual narrative. In my opinion, it was well done. By allowing you to fill in the blanks of the missing years to explain how the children became the adults they are, the show tricked us into feeling like there was a lot more character developments than was actually shown. A smart move considering how many people we had to get to know in only 12 episodes.

And I still agree with all of this. The tie travel genre is not for everyone and I do understand the common complaints. But one thing it does have going for it is the sense of journey. It allows writers to put their characters through so many situations and perspectives in a relatively short amount of time/words that viewers will get to experience way more. For the record, I think Futurama is one of the shows that really handles time travel well.

Erased Review

Ahh the good old future days

The murder mystery part of the story is equally well handled. They only reveal the killer fairly late in the series giving you plenty of time to suspect everyone. I thought I knew who it was but then I changed my mind and then I changed it again, and again… You can, and probably a lot of you will, figure it out fairly early on but there are a lot of red herrings thrown in to keep things fun. And unlike some shows, the red herrings make sense. Besides, even when the mystery is completely cleared up the show remains quite suspenseful and the tense atmosphere is very well sustained throughout most of the series. Unfortunately, the final confrontation is a bit lackluster as the killer seems to have grown sloppy and lazy with age. 

I have to say, even though I remember most of the series in detail, the killer is kind of a blur. Honestly, they were the most boring character in the series, and they have a very standard, evil cause evil (or possibly evil cause crazy) characterization and motivation. Since Erased isn’t in fact about the killer or even really about the murder. It’s about Satoru’s self-actualization and about taking charge of one’s future, a weak antagonist isn’t that big a deal. But it is one of the aspects that could have been improved upon. It would have heightened the murder mystery plot point and evened out the separate story threads. As it is, Erased has some very strong elements with more mediocre and weak ones weaved in with makes it a bit of an unbalanced watching experience.

Shhesh – I said I was going to make this more positive but it’s sure not looking that way. I really liked a lot of the stuff other people didn’t. The flash forward and the latter half of the series were a huge win for me!…

Erased Review Sachiko dead

I almost put in a pic of the killer – or maybe I did…

 The shows weakest point, and the aspect that seems to be the source of most of the differences in opinion, are the relationships between the main characters. These are indeed a mixed bag. For instance, I think Satoru’s relationship with his mom is pure awesomness. His implied relationship with his coworker is, potentially illegal…. A lot of people believe that the heart of the narrative is the relationship between Satoru and Kayo and were therefore disappointed by the fact that they don’t ultimately end up “together”. On the other hand, I thought that conclusion was not only perfectly logical but also just better. He was not rescuing some damsel in distress and then claiming the prize, he was saving a friend, because that’s what good guys actually do. Moreover, the story is told from his point of view, and to him, their relationship was not really about “them” it was always about “him”. Satoru certainly cares for Kayo, he wants her to be happy and in fact, he’s willing to sacrifice almost anything for that, but that’s because she is his goal. Kayo represents his purpose, the idea of saving her finally gives him some badly needed direction and that is what is principal here: Satoru must save Kayo, everything else is just variables.

I honestly don’t remember this general discussion in the fan community, but it makes sense. I did always think that Kayo was not particularly well developed but for the reasons mentioned above, it didn’t bother me. I didn’t feel like it was necessary for the story being told.

On the other hand, there’s Kenya. At the time, I remember being fascinated by Kenya. What did he know, why did he seem so incisive, how did he fit into the story? Was he the killer? Was he also time travelling? Kenya was one of the most developed characters in Erased and they dropped a lot of cryptic clues around him and then… nothing. It almost felt like the writers forgot he even existed. I wonder if he was lost in adaptation. To this day I feel this lack of resolve when it comes to Kenya’s character. Maybe he should get a spin off…

Erased Review

I’m not saying they weren’t sweet together

To me, to real beating heart of the story was his relationship with Sachiko. We do not get to explore the mother-son dynamics in detail very often in anime and when we do it’s usually more Psycho than anything else. Sachiko is the best, she just is. She’s a chain smoking smart mouth full of faults and weaknesses which she carries with grace and strength. She never fails to be exactly what a parent should. Her courage comes from fear of the worse, her determination from desperation and her understanding from…being the best…. As one of the great benefits of the flexible time jumping premise, we get to see how Sachiko interacts with Satoru under some very different circumstances. We see them as she tries to push her lackadaisical grown son into doing something, anything with his life. We see them as she watches her little boy go to school and start coping with some very serious issues by himself, trying to figure out just how much she can let him go and how much she should shield him. We see her desperately taking care of a bedridden adult child that might not wake up, never giving up hope because the alternative is simply unbearable. And what’s more, we see all of this through his eyes. This is both special and beautiful.

Can’t argue with anything here. Sachiko remains one of my favourite mother characters.

Erased Review Sachiko Mom

I know, right

Defenders of this series will often say that there is no stated romantic relationship between Sachiko and Airi, and it is a purely platonic friendship between a cute 16-year-old girl that has a stated interest in him, and a 29-year-old man. I dunno guys – I certainly got the sexy times vibe and I’m not usually prone to seeing romance where it isn’t made obvious. Honestly, why would you even think of those nice basketball boys doing those things? The fact that this is dropped in the latter half of a series that is so vehement about the importance of protecting children from predators left me with a sour taste in my mouth. It was a sore spot in an otherwise thoroughly enjoyable show.

I forgot Airi existed. Maybe it’s because this element was not really my cup of tea or maybe it just wasn’t that present or important and happened to be on my mind when writing tis review because you see it in the closing episode. With time, the last few episode faded from my memory and I remember that more central parts of the plot mostly.

I remember them fondly. To the point where I’m considering rewatching the series. I never rewatch series. This is a big deal!

When Erased came out, it made a big splash. Everyone was talking about it for a while. It even got popular enough to get the live action treatment. I haven’t seen that adaptation and I don’t feel the need to. It’s been 4 years now. So, has Erased stood the test of time? Will anyone still be talking about it in another 4 years?

Erased Review

We’re just friends!

Favourite character: Sachiko of course but honourable mention goes to Kenya.

What this anime taught me about myself: I don’t call my mom enough

“I feel bad for people who don’t drink. When they wake up in the morning, that’s as good as they’re going to feel all day.”

Suggested drink: Second chance

  • Every time Satoru what he’s thinking out loud – take a swig
  • Every time wonder guy is mentioned or his mask is shown – take a swig
  • Every time you suspect someone of being the killer – take notes
  • Every time Kayo asks if someone is stupid – take a swig
  • Every time Kayo fails to react – take a good swig and don’t make a face
  • Every time Sachiko is a magnificent badass – call your mom
  • Every time Kayo is wearing red – take a swig
  • Every time Satoru jumps in time – check your watch
  • Every time  someone says mata (ja mata – mata ne…) – take a swig
  • Every time we see an adult version of the kids – take a swig

Erased Review

 

Irina

I'm much nicer than I seem, we should be friends!

You may also like...

18 Responses

  1. If I didn’t make this clear on the original (if I ever read it – I don’t remember reading it if I did), I liked all of this anime bar the ending and according to this post and the comments, that seems to be the general consensus. (Update: I never did read the original…which is why I don’t remember it in the first place.)

    I don’t think I saw the Satoru x Airi ship going anywhere, although I think I understand why shippers see it that way. Satoru x Kayo could’ve worked in the past, but probably not in the present (and you do see why at the end).

    I do believe there is a Kayo spinoff out there in manga form (it’s probably Japan-only…), although I can’t say the same for Kenya.

  2. foovay says:

    I actually HATE time travel. I can be reading a series description and the minute the two words “time travel” come up, I’m done. No thank you. Erased slipped in by intriguing me with a picture and before I knew it, well, it didn’t matter because I was too involved, too invested, and I wanted to KNOW what happened. I really did like this series. Hubby ran onto the live action and we both enjoyed it as well. It is a gripping story with well done atmospherics. I don’t even mind that it time travels, because it just doesn’t feel like the typical time traveling show. I don’t even mind if Irina time traveled to review a review of Erased. 😛 couldn’t resist.

  3. Dawnstorm says:

    Revisiting an old review and it’s Erased? Kind of fitting.

    Me, I barely ever think of this show, and I’ve forgotten most of it. Sachiko was awesome – definitely one of the best anime mums. Some scenes with Kayo were stunning. And it was mostly okay to watch. All in all, it’s just a show I watched.

    I do think I remember some disappointed response as it aired, but those voices died down after the show finished, and ever since I only ever hear the people who liked it talk about the show. It seems to be the type of show you either like/love or forget.

  4. K.A.L.T says:

    After reading your post I’m sad to say that I can barely remember anything that happened. All I can remember is that I really enjoyed the series but heard people saying that everything was good but the ending. Also, I don’t think Kenya was the most developed? If I remember correctly he was just seemed wayyy too mature for his age and stuff.

    On a side note, it’s not “tie travel genre” but “time travel genre” haha. XD

    Also, interesting that you made no mention of Steins;Gate when talking about anime that did time travel well though (personally I can’t really tell good from bad cause I’m not mentally competent enough to tell what makes sense and what doesn’t but I know generally people agree that steins;gate handles time travel really well)

  5. This reminds me…. wasn’t I going to review Erased. AAAAAAHHHH I need to review it, there’s so much to discuss. I do really like it though, I consider it one of the most cinematic and atmospheric series I’ve seen and I think the visual presentation elevates kind of standard story.

    There’s quite a bit of valid and absurd criticism due to this show’s popularity so I want to put my hat in that ring. Thanks, now I have to compete with this great review from not only past Irina but also present Irina; always glad to hear your thoughts.

  6. J A Reyes says:

    I haven’t tried this one yet. It sounds pretty good! Thank you 🙂

  7. alsmangablog says:

    This was a very fun post to read! Having your current thoughts interspersed throughout the old review was a great way to structure the post and I enjoyed seeing how your perspective on the show had changed over the years.

Leave me a comment and make my day!

%d bloggers like this: