- Genre : Slice of Life, Supernatural, Science Fiction, Romance, Comedy
- Episodes: 14
- Studio: Kyoto Animation
Timelords, and espers, and aliens, Oh My! Do you ever long for a life less ordinary? For just a touch of supernatural to liven up those drab days? Haruhi Suzumiya sure does, and that’s a problem for us all. Because whether she realizes it or not, Haruhi is a girl who gets what she wants. Smart, imaginative, strong willed and beautiful, nothing can stand for very long in her way. The fact is, when she sets her mind on something, she will make it happen, even if she has to wrap the very fabric of reality in the process. Now, if she could just figure out what it is she actually wants.
Sometimes I feel like I exist in a reality that’s only tangentially related to everyone else’s. Maybe the disconnect lies in my inability to properly perceive the world around me? I’m pretty sure it’s everyone else that’s wrong. In my world, the Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya is a titan, a surrealist classic that I had inexplicably failed to watch up until now due to lack of availability. Crunchyroll licensed it for Canadian distribution in November. Guess what happened. Go on, guess!
To be honest, I had believed that Haruhi was roughly the same generation as Neon Genesis Evangelion and with that in mind, I was blown away by the animation and art. It was in fact made in 2006 and there are quite a few things that date the series.
The art is actually quite nice, it has a certain traditional look to it, like it could have come from a different era but it’s certainly pretty and detailed. What’s more, it’s almost unwavering in quality which is impressive and rare even in modern offerings. The animation on the other hand doesn’t quite live up to today’s standards. They try to cover it up with dramatic music, sweeping camera movements and slight visual quirks but there’s just a ridiculous amount of still shots in this show. As much of the narration comes from the protagonist’s stream of consciousness, we regularly get second long scenes without so much as talking animation. Even in what should be high action battle scenes, the characters stand more or less motionless as speed lines and abstract colors explode around them. For what it’s worth, the distractions are well done but once you notice, it’s really hard to unsee. Sorry. However, by far the most outdated element in my opinion, is the fanservice. There’s not a ton of it but what there is completely clashes with the rest of the show and just feels awkward. You can almost hear the guy in the writer’s room saying: well we **need** to throw in some t&a somewhere…
On the plus side, the voice acting is quite good, especially when it comes to leading man and narrator Kyon, voiced by the great Tomokazu Sugita (of Gintama fame). This guy is a master of the irreverent voice coupled with surprisingly expressive intonations (also voicing my beloved alien angel Yusuke Kitagawa in Persona 5). His delivery really adds to the experience and was one of the biggest factors keeping vested in this show.
I had been hearing vague whisperings of the story of Haruhi for years. The seemingly odd disjointed mish mash of thematic elements was what had sparked my interest in the series to begin with. Not so much the actual story mind you, more the idea. A light slice of life take on existential sci-fi with theological speculations. Sounds fancy, right? The first few episodes really align with that, as new surreal characters are introduced one after the other and we slowly start to unravel the bizarre mystery of Haruhi’s existence. I could see traces of Serial Experiments Lain as the very nature of reality was present as subject to Haruhi’s unknowing whims while the supporting characters gathering around her occasionally reminded me of the cast of Neon Genesis Evangelion. You know, without the melodrama. I believe the idea was to take all these high concept philosophical/psychological sci-fi musings and meld them with a traditional student slice of life setting with just a touch of harem.
It’s a fantastic idea. Being a huge fan of genre melding animes I just couldn’t resist. Sadly, what i found was that the whole never quite came together in a cohesive way. The deep convoluted storyline promised in the first few episodes doesn’t get the development it needs to ever come to any sort of satisfying dénouement and seems to get brushed aside as the series takes on a decidedly school club feel. For instance, a rogue alien operative that is the only clear antagonist of the show, is both introduced and summarily dispatched in a single episode, allowing for some striking scenes but very little long-term impact.
On the other hand, that surreal exposition heavy part of the storyline robs us of time we would have normally spent bonding with the characters, making them seem a little too hollow to carry the series on the strengths of their personalities alone. I just couldn’t muster enough empathy for them to care about their amateur baseball game or whatever random activity of the week they chose to pursue. You can see what the creative team was aiming for but somewhere along the way, it seems they lost sight of it.
This is not to say that I didn’t like it. I did enjoy some of the episodes quite a bit. The two-part murder mystery spoof was engaging, and I was genuinely interested in finding out who dunnit and every single spec of half thought out technobabble had me taking deligent notes for future reference. But overall, I kept waiting for them to go back to the supernatural elements and they just didn’t. It left me feeling like I had watched a season of filler episodes.
This is just season one mind you and there’s clearly a lot more space for the narrative to grow. If it had never continued, I would have considered it a failure but it did have enough potential to get me interested in watching the second season. Although most of the characters are no more than pro forma archetypes for now, they are pleasant and established enough to possibly flesh out in interesting ways. They also work quite well as an ensemble cast, making their various relationships actually interesting to explore and I look forward to seeing where each of them goes.
Fittingly however, both the greatest strength and biggest weakness of the show is Haruhi herself. Haruhi is not exactly a pleasant character. Selfish, spoiled and inconsiderate, I would hate to have her as a friend. I also saw so much of myself in her. Clueless and a little insecure, Haruhi has no idea what she’s doing to the people around her and I truly believe she would be sad if she found out. Not that she would admit it. There seems to be a rich anime tradition of casting unknowing teenage girls as gods of some sort, but this is the only time I could truly relate to one. Haruhi isn’t a very good god and I would be a horrible one. Seeing an omnipotent being that’s neither malevolent nor uncaring but simply inept was an amusing concept and oddly, a little comforting. To think the powers that be are disgusted and fed up of us is sad but if they’re just bad at their job, they could get better, right?
There’s a huge poetic irony at the center of The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya. Haruhi, a being potentially capable of manifesting her will and desperate for a touch of the extraordinary is the only one who doesn’t get to take part in the remarkable phenomenon happening all around her. And in the end, this is a metaphor for the season as well. We see the promise of the spectacular get shackled by the mundane and end up with mere glimpses of something astounding we can’t quite make out.
Now let’s see if that second season gives us a better picture!
Rei Yuki Nagato
I am being sober in moderation…
Suggested drink: The Godmother
- Every time Haruhi physically drags someone – take a sip
- Every time Haruhi gives a thumbs up – take a sip
- Every time Haruhi sexually harasses Asahina – sigh
- Every time anyone says “3 years ago” – take a sip
- Every time Kyon walks in on a girl changing – fan yourself
- Every time Haruhi strips – take a sip
- Every time we see Ryoko – take a sip
- Every time Kyon commutes to or from school – take a sip
- Every time Asahina says “classified information” – frown
- Every time future Asahina shows up – take a sip
- Every time we see an enclosed space – take a sip
- Every time Kyn says “yare yare” – raise your glass
35 thoughts on “The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya and Mine”
That’s one anime I remember watching back then. I had mixed thoughts about that show. There were some legitimately funny moments and the animation was good. However, I couldn’t stand Haruhi’s Protagonist Centered Morality moments as a lead character.
For me, I think the show was a victim of its own hype. I probably would have enjoyed it more if I wasn’t expecting The Best Show Ever!
Oh, I agree. I get hype backlash/aversion moments so much. I’m sure I’ve mentioned this sentiment in some of my reviews, but for me, it’s either “Okay, it’s good, but not THAT good.” or “Seriously?!? Are these people watching the same thing I’m watching?”. It’s such a glaring dichotomy more often than not. Sure, there are times where I do agree with the praise to something like a Haibane Renmei or Song of the Sea (if we’re talking Western animation), but it’s partially because they weren’t so widespread in their popularity if that makes sense.
I totally understand the criticism that the Haruhi series gets. Even so, it’s actually one of my personal favorites. It should be noted that there are two different ways to watch the series: in either the broadcast order or the chronological order. I won’t get into too many details here, so for anyone is curious here is a Wikipedia page devoted to the matter: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_The_Melancholy_of_Haruhi_Suzumiya_episodes
ah yeah – I go into that a bit more in the s2 review. I should say I enjoyed the second season a lot.
Grr, this didn’t come up in my reader. Just found it by going into your blog
I feel your pain
While I love Haruhi I do get the criticism the show gets. A friend of mine tried to watch it with me and after three episodes said she couldn’t because she just couldn’t stand Haruhi herself. Thanks for sharing your thoughts on the show.
she does get better.. As much as I called her unlikable I definetly understand her. Boredom is tough.
Ohhh, this post makes me want to re-watch it (I really need to). Haruhi was the prototype waifu for the longest time, lol
I admire your love of strong willed ladies. Kudos!
I tried to watch this anime but ended up dropping it… Although the movie seems to have nice ratings xD but without the Anime I don’t think I’ll watch the movie xp
I can understand why. I haven’t seen the movie yet but I’m intrigued
And not surprisingly I haven’t seen this one (what do you mean again? 😂). Seriously though, despite it’s flaws and an apparently annoying main character, something still makes me want to see this one. So maybe I will add this to my anime theme month which will probably be next on my blog. As always though, your review was another terrific piece of writing! Awesome stuff 😊😊
The annoying main character is a lot like me….
With one really BIG difference…./you are not annoying, not in any way 😊
Remeber this moment…
Lol…I will remember this moment: but I would like to bet on the fact that I will never find you annoying (Remember this moment as well 😉).
I really enjoyed both seasons (one more so than two in terms of individual parts), but the movie is where it is at! It’s long but I thought it was the best film tied to a series I’ve seen to date. Enjoyed reading 🙂
The movie seems amazing – I haven’t seen it yet
I think you’ll be in for a real treat. By no means perfect but since you used some NGE comparisons here, it gave me strong End of Eva vibes mixed with Stiens;Gate. I mean ‘nough said, right?
Now that’s a hard sell
I’m just really passionate about the film XD I thought people were seriously overhyping it before I watched it.
There’s a lot of material in the original light novels that didn’t wind up getting animated, and a lot of it is quite interesting.
What’s also interesting is that Endless eight was based off of a story in the books that was told once and never repeated.
That’s interesting – I’m not sure how I feel about it. The repetitiveness sort of made that storyline.
I’d take one very long sigh (till I lose my breath and faint) seeing how many harassment memes are repeatedly posted on 9gag 😛
To be honest, I haven’t seen the second season of this show so I should do that too, but I did like the first season and skipped my way to the movie…
At some point I should face the second season, but I should probably rewatch this one first. Thanks for the reminder.
Personally I think the second season is more…decisive.
“Now let’s see if that second season gives us a better picture!”
Oh, it’ll give exactly eight!!!!!
Also, a lot of the intentions of the anime is really diluted at this point, but this anime is one of the first ones to try strong meta into its narrative. I saw the anime a long time ago, but people positively responded to this anime because of its meta cynical approach to the industry itself. It was honestly groundbreaking at the time, especially since everyone, and their mother, was dancing the ED.
But dated? I guess if you look at an anime w/ today’s standards. I always see anime as time capsules of its era, so it never becomes dated to me but that’s an interesting point though, hmmm
The art style is very classical for something that came out in mid 2000. To me it looked mid 90s at first glance
To be honest i already finished s2 and wrote my review. I believe it includes the word metacommentary
Kyon’s monologue was the best part of the anime, and I’ll raise my glass to that.
He was consistently great to listen to