Prophylaxis is a key concept of positional chess. It is a move, or sequence of moves, to deal with an opponent’s plan before it starts. Sometimes one can completely stop the threat; sometimes one just makes the plan relatively harmless.
You make me wish I had studied chess instead of learning just enough to get slaughtered in the one college tournament I entered… Oh, this is Crow, and I’ll use the bold font this week!
I must say, I really look forward to this show each week. It’s one of the few seasonal series I’ve watched that I can honestly say I can never wait until the next episode. If this was all out – I probably would have binged it in a day or two.

Even though so far it’s brought a heck of a lot more questions than answers, it doesn’t bother me. For some reason I am confident that The Promised Neverland does know the answers and will eventually share them with us, unlike let’s just say…BoogiePop. What do you think Crow, are we just being led astray?
Remember Lost? It was a television series back in 2004. It was famous for coming up with all these outrageous ideas, stunning plot twists, and inscrutable characters. But early on I suspected what the writing team eventually admitted: They had no idea where they were going.
We might be wrong, but I see every sign that this writing team knows precisely what they’re doing. And they’re really good at it!

We start things off with Sister’s offer. A very uneasy alliance to say the least. None of the reveals here were particularly surprising to me. I had always assumed that the caretakers were former farm kids and although I hadn’t thought about them having a kill switch, it fits perfectly with the universe we’ve come to know. It does bring up a question I thought of later, but we’ll get back to that. I think this opening scene served largely to show us that Krone isn’t as far gone as we may have thought.
I must say, there were a few moments during her speech where she seemed quite wistful. Sister isn’t dumb and she may not be entirely crazy, but she’s quite broken. I don’t think she ever reconciled herself with the reality the way Mom has (or even Ray…)
That lack of acceptance means she could never adjust her thinking, and it really showed later in this episode! She should not have been caught like she was!
The following scene had the kids reassess their situation. Once again Norman did his super wizkid act, seeing through Krone’s intentions (i.e. that she doesn’t have authority or credibility to turn them in so she’s looking for proof), while Emma was a tower of strength and Gilda showed timid caution. But did you see Don ask that super fair strategic question? Nevermind if they can trust Krone, do they even need her? Can they simply shut her out. It’s a great question and no one else asked. Go Don!
Now that they’ve showed they actually trust him, he’s finding his footing. I like how he’s developing.

This show is starting to make a habit out of leaving things unshown… We had Norman’s laugh and realization last time, now Emma’s favour. Emma asked something out of Gilda and Don she didn’t want Norman to hear. That is so out of character. Any idea what it might be?
I’m guessing it’s something Emma, Norman, and Ray can’t easily do. They know they’re under enhanced scrutiny. Something to help get the kids ready? Unobtrusively gathering supplies? And as I watched the scene, I wondered if she didn’t want Norman and Ray to know, or if she and Norman and Ray had arranged for that moment? As a demonstration of trust in Don and Gilda? But using a falsehood to demonstrate trust seems counter productive. I guess all that’s a fancy way of saying “I got nothing!”
I got to say there was some interesting CG this episode. The panning shot in the hallway as Emma and Norman gor the Sister’s room. Later the distorting close up on their faces as Sister closes in on them. The episode also used out of focus shots i a large number of scenes. I think this may be thematic. Things are getting murky… Maybe not. Anyways, not a bad way to spruce up visuals in another dialogue heavy episode.
Also, when Sister Krone approached them, did you see how they had to crane their necks father and farther back as she got closer! That really emphasized how tall she was — and how small they were.
It was a great way to add to the atmosphere.

Unlike the opening scene, the conversation in Krone’s room was a treasure trove of information. But not exactly in what she said. I want to go through these with you, so please put up with me for a bit.
It’s a pivotal scene, so please take your time! I think the scene need a lot of unpacking!
I realized in the middle of the scene that something had been bothering me since the beginning. Actually, it was Krone’s use of the word “Headquarters”. This implies something limited. It’s not a country she didn’t talk about the Capital, the Palace or City Hall. It’s not a word usually associated with political leadership. She also didn’t talk about a Cathedral or Temple or anything that would give the idea of a religious or spiritual place. A headquarters is usually reserved for specific organizations with some type of mission, and more often than not competition or even adversaries. We use it for companies, armies, thieves guilds….Maybe I’m making way to much of these, it was a translation after all. Still it stuck with me.
I had assumed it was corporate, but now you have me wondering! Just what are these demons?

The second unspoken revelation was that humans not eaten do exist. They make the clothes and bring materials. There was those books last week so we kinda had an inkling. Great revelation but the real question is why. Why are there free humans that exist, that the kids could just mix with? Why would those humans help the “demons”? (Krone seemed quite amused at the word). This doesn’t quite mesh with the idea of a world so overrun with monsters that the only way the can even get delicious delicious huma flesh is to grow it themselves… I figured there were breeding grounds but whole industries. Uncontrolled enough that 12 year old kids would go unnoticed?
Did you notice Sister Krone said that the humans were considered more or less their equals (“equal standing”)? That just reinforces the questions you just asked. It’s almost like the kids in Grace Field, Plant Three, are behind enemy lines, and the human nations are trying to give them aid.
There’s something so mundanely farm-like about the phrase “Grace Field, Plant Three” that’s chilling.
My farm knowledge is limited…they sounded like sects to me.
That’s even worse!

And here’s the last one, the one that was actually from the opening scene but only hit me at this point, after I started wondering about the free humans… Why does Sister have a kill switch? Why would they care if a single Mother or sister escaped? Why would they care if dozens did? If the world is hostile and inhospitable to humans, that will already be a deterrent to most, and who cares about the few exceptions? Unless the world isn’t that difficult to survive in… And the “demons’ ” numbers are too small for more direct patrolling… Maybe?
That’s another thing that made it seem like the kids are in a prisoners of war camp (but are produced by breeding instead of captured). The demons don’t want anyone escaping to tell the human nations what’s up? All conjecture, of course…
And who’s this “Him” that Sister Krone mentioned? What’d you think of Sister Krone’s diabolical laugh before she schooled Emma and Norman on the art of deception — and showing them how far they were from mastering it?
Oh yeah another puzzle for us…assuming we can trust a word Krone says. This is kinda the thesis of the episode…

And at this point we catch up with Ray and Mom. I like Ray, and I’m pretty sure Isabella does too. He was quite endearing with his excitement over the camera. Even though he just wanted it as a tool, he’s still into it like any kid would be.
Did you find that as heart-breaking as I did? I used to tear into cameras and radios and engines when I was his age. We shared a curiosity that made me nostalgic — until I remembered he’s about to be shipped out.
I am weirdly attached to Ray. For some reason I want to comfort him most. Maybe because he was carrying the burden by himself for so long.

At the end of this scene, Mom crosses off a date in the calendar and says “Well now, I think it’s about time”. Who was she talking to? Ray was long gone and there was no indication anyone came in. She was looking at the camera. Was this a sudden 4th wall break for no reason?
I wonder in retrospect if it had anything to do with the letter Isabella handed to Sister Krone?
I thought about that too. Still weird of Mom to talk to herself…

Sister isn’t dumb but she underestimates her opponents.
Fatally, I think. And speaking of the letter Isabella handed her, did you see Isabella’s expression? Is she as cold as ice and hard as steel or what? Dang, I’d hate to play poker against her!
Oh Mom remains one of the most threatening antagonists I’ve seen in a long long time. She might be on par with Griffith. That’s saying a lot.
I’m not sure who the kid that interrupts Krone is, but they should leave him behind. He is DEFINITELY going to slow them down…
On a Christmas tree, he likely would not be the brightest bulb or LED.

OK well now the show did it again – WHAT’S IN THE NOTE!!!???!!! AND in the letter from “Headquarters”. GWAHHHH tell me!!!
Did you see what Sister Krone did when she saw the letter opener? Did she try to defend herself? Preemptively try to disable Isabella, since she’s so much bigger? No. She winced and closed her eyes, waiting for the fatal strike. Isabella is flat-out scary!
So um, there’s only 5 episodes left. Either that’s gonna be one smooth escape or everyone’s gonna die real quick. Or we are looking at season 1 of more… The manga is ongoing and there’s at least two season’s worth already published so… Thoughts?
There’s no way they can resolve this in five episodes, and just from a business perspective, they’d be foolish to artificially cut this short. They have to see it through to the end, so it’s season 1 of x, isn’t it?
Or what if it’s like Gray’s Anatomy, where they periodically bring a new class of kids in to replace those who didn’t make it? Each successive class gets closer and closer to escape… I’m not sure my heart could take it!
What’s amazing to me is that the writers have been able to maintain the level of tension — with so little action! I was on the edge of my seat after Sister Krone found the note under Ray’s bed. And we didn’t even find out what it said!
Good stuff…
Very good stuff!
- The Promised Neverland Episode 1
- The Promised Neverland Episode 2
- The Promised Neverland Episode 3
- The Promised Neverland Episode 4
- The Promised Neverland Episode 5
- The Promised Neverland Episode 6
And here are a whole bunch more pictures for you!
Mom is so crafty as her true nature is revealed more and more thoroughout the series. Especially in episodes 7 and 8. Ep. 8 really got me good!
I KNOW!-! ZOMG
Girl I made a post reviewing this show and I straight up said, “There hasn’t been this big of a mystery since we found out about the basement in AOT!” What is beyond those walls?!?!
I’m three days late, oh well…
One more thought, you guys make a pretty good complementary combo. Thank you for these posts!
Thank you so much! I’m sure I speak for Crow as well. We really appreciate it!
Yep!
This show is starting to make a habit out of leaving things unshown… We had Norman’s laugh and realization last time, now Emma’s favour. Emma asked something out of Gilda and Don she didn’t want Norman to hear. That is so out of character. Any idea what it might be?
Yeah, what was Norman’s laugh all about? Just finding Ray’s tough / self-interested act during that scene goofy, since he knows just how much Ray cares about Emma & him?
As for Emma, last episode showed that she’s much more perceptive than we (or at least I) had initially thought. She must know Ray plans to trick her to let the rest of the kids go, and she may have read Norman’s acquiescence from his body language. That would be my guess.
Why are there free humans that exist, that the kids could just mix with? Why would those humans help the “demons”?
And here’s the last one, the one that was actually from the opening scene but only hit me at this point, after I started wondering about the free humans… Why does Sister have a kill switch? Why would they care if a single Mother or sister escaped? Why would they care if dozens did? If the world is hostile and inhospitable to humans, that will already be a deterrent to most, and who cares about the few exceptions?
Imagine… Imagine if HQ actually stood for Hannibal Quarters? The world’s ecosystem being actually lead by cannibal humans, who would do whatever it takes to keep their quirks out the public eye. That would be so terribly depraved! Although surely the show would end just after the escape… That can’t be it, those characters wouldn’t have suffered enough!
I wouldn’t put it past this show!
Promise Neverland is amazing, just binged watched it yesterday.
Oh my. That seems like a wild experience
Yeah wanted to catch up on anime I bookmarked that I thought would be interesting.
Prophylaxis also refers to preventative medicine and birth control. 🙂
indeed
I’m just liking all this again because I want to think of something other than my depression that I still have and has given me an emotional breakdown for literally half the day.
I guess I never thought about there being human empires. I thought of the book stamps as from something from thirty years ago (because the episode titles are apparently dates) who wrote some hints in books before he escaped demon rule in order to start a rebellion? Still a lot to infer here.
Wasn’t there a book with a stamp that had been published the same year?
I guess I just caught the year fifteen myself. I may need to rewatch that scene again.
I don’t know mind you, I could be completely wrong but we do know there are some humans around… I guess…if we can trust Krone which is not a given
Yeah, there should be a don’t trust Krone rule.
I’m curious what you two are making of Phil given he’s still loitering around and being conspicuous episode after episode. I still can’t figure out where they are going with him and I really want to know.
The Phil conspiracy. Like I said to Dawnstorm, I think he’s just Isabella’s next spy. She is shipping Ray out soon so she needs another informant. But his creepily cheerful design is somewhat jarring. Ray almost always looks angry and depressed which is what you would expect under the circumstances. But Phil is ecstatic…
I wish I could offer an alternate view, but I think Irina’s right. There’s just something about Phil being so cheerful that’s unnerving in this context!
right!?!
I know. It is the characterisation that makes me wonder if he knows the whole story or not. I’m really curious as to what is going on there.
The again he may be a plant from “the outside”
Phil is a cute Innocent boy😍😍. He’s a light in the dark world lol, but he would make a good spy 🤔
You are so easy to dupe!
Lol yeah I might be a bit too much like Emma or more like Norman trying to see the best in everyone
It’s not a bad thing
The kid from the screenshot? I think he’s genetically engineered not to physically age, and he’s Isabella’s boss. There’s one like that in every plant. I mean look at that eternally dopey smile. You can’t trust him.
Seriously, I think that’s Phil, the kid who showed Emma the stamps. I’m not sure what his deal is, but the above paragraph is only half a joke. Maybe it’s the way he keeps suddenly appearing, and that he sort of reminds me of Village of the Damned… I don’t trust that what we see is what we get.
Also, I’m fairly sure what Krone found was a plant, and if it contains a weakpoint of Isabella’s that might have been deliberate. Ray might be escalating their conflict somehow. I mean, if Krone knows without a doubt that her plan is going to fail, and if she feels that she’s no longer trusted, she seems like the sort of person to take Isabella down with her, if she can. (Sounds like a plan Emma wouldn’t aprove of, too, and has thus conflict potential.)
I also don’t really think I’m right with any of that (except that the little boy is Phil; I just checked on MAL). My track record with this show isn’t so great.
Phil again! Phil is definitely way too present for comfort. Most likely he’s the next Ray but that’s way more boring than your explanation.
I also think that Ray basically set Kron and Isabella on each other. A good move, but I wonder how he did it. Ry doesn’t really have much information that Isabella needs at this point.
“A good move, but I wonder how he did it. Ry doesn’t really have much information that Isabella needs at this point.”
Do you remember the chess game that Ikta described in Alderamin on the Sky (was it chess?) where the two players don’t directly see each other’s moves? Ray vs Isabella kinda reminds me of that.
Kriegspiel?
That big smack you probably heard? Yeah, that was me smacking my forehead. You have not only have heard of the chess variant, you named it. In a title. In a post we collaborated on. Just last month.
I _seem_ to remember a time when I could remember things… But maybe I’m mistaken!
🙂
We learned this episode that the staff they recruit from the kids are always girls (if Krone is to be trusted on this), and that’s consistent with Ray being a spy but not being recruited. That sort of bothers me: wouldn’t be more efficient to have your recruits be spies? Maybe you just don’t need that many recruits but you always need spies? Phil being the next one, or a back-up, would make sense.
I’m also curious how Ray did it. Made up some random weakness (I had the impression he put a weakness Krone already knows about into that piece of paper, but there’s nothing in my memories to make this definite), and he faked that letter from headquaters (because he obviously knows how to sound like them and has made a fake seal, because he’s awesome like that)… I might have to rethink this.
Th lettre doesn’t need to be fake. Momma may have started that ball rolling herself.
I know. In fact, I think it’s real. But I’d love the chaos that could ensue if it wasn’t.
“I think he’s genetically engineered not to physically age, and he’s Isabella’s boss. There’s one like that in every plant. I mean look at that eternally dopey smile. You can’t trust him.”
Dude! You come up with the most diabolical — and really plausible! — explanations!
That’s exactly what a demon raising livestock should do! No one would suspect him — and by the time they did, they’d be shipped out.
Now I’m more curious than ever to see what Phil’s up to!