This was one of these episodes that inspired a myriad of post titles. “A smart looking guy”, “An un-individualistic face”… in the end I had to go with Probatio Diabolica because it was just too cool.
Ok, I thought it was cool which might not be the best reference. Probation Diabolica is what Dojima said was on the blank car plates. It’s also a relatively obscure legal term used when it is believed that the burden of proof is unreasonable. It’s actually described as a logical dilemma that while evidence will prove the existence of something, the lack of evidence fails to disprove it. As in while substantial evidence may prove the devil’s existence, there is no evidence that denies the devil’s existence; therefore, one cannot deny the devil’s existence. Impossible proof.
You gotta admit, that’s a fun little thing to slip into a show like Pretty Boy Detective Club. Especially in this arc!
I’m gonna roughly divide the episodes into two halves. The one with Soutoin’s brother and the one with the Vice-President. But before we get started, that was quite the surprise fanservice opening. There was an odd, detached quality to it and I think just the pure bizarreness of the scene made me enjoy it quite a bit. It really was a snarky send-off to harem tropes, both reverse and traditional.
Also before we get started, let me share this with you. It’s basically what I attempt and fail to do in my living room every Sunday. YouTube seemed to want to mock me by recommending the video but it backfired as I have been enjoying it tremendously!
Ok, let’s start with the actual episode. No wait, one more story thought. Have I mentioned that Pretty Boy Detective club is a beautiful show?
In the first half of the episode with got to meet the founder of the Pretty Boy Detective Club and the older brother of the current leader. And he was a guy. As Dojima put it, a smart-looking guy. I can’t possibly hope to capture or explain the scene. There were a lot of words of course but particularly poignant. Or at least, they spoke to me.
Odoru Soutouin was once Odourou the storyteller. And I have to admit, few things are as beautiful or frightening as the storyteller. But now, he’s just not anymore. And Dojima has this monologue, the tales of the past and she just muses that he’s a nice, polite ordinary guy and he no longer thinks about being pretty, or being a boy, or being a detective. He’s definitely an old friend but he’s not part of the team anymore. It was a cutting speech.
The subtext is obvious. A sort of melancholy on the things we give up when we grow up. on how magic fades and everyone must become an adult someday. Dojima and Nagahiro wonder if they’ll forget their time being Pretty Boy Detectives. They don’t tend to say that Manabu looks a lot like his brother. And the unspoken message that is nevertheless screaming through the first half is ordinary isn’t pretty.
Dojima’s school election posters are amazing! I would hang that on my wall!
The things, you might thing someone is dull and ordinary when in fact they are extraordinary and fascinating and it’s just tat you have failed to see it. Even a mundane and un-striking sort of guy can be keeping an astonishing secret.
I was still spinning from that first half when I got thrown in the rollercoaster that was the second. So many likely and thematically significant theories were brought up and then discarded in just about 10 minutes. Not to mention that we got to meet the world’s friendliest ice princess. I haven’t seen Frozen, I could be wrong. The Vice-president was very charming and outgoing is what I’m saying.
I did not dislike the theory that there had been no accident. That the vice-president actually wanted a directional change in the school leadership and had made up an excuse to drop out. It’s a good explanation, logical and realistic. It opens up the possibility of some sort of betrayal and of course potential tragedy for the club. Narratively, it works quite well if a little uninspired.
But uninspired would be a travesty for Pretty Boy Detective Club. Unacceptable! And of course, that’s just not what it is. In the Edogawa story, it’s one of the short stories about his detective Akechi of course, there’s that classic trope where the narrator (who isn’t the detective) gathers all the other characters and basically tells them exactly what happened. What really did happen was not that interesting but the narrator’s version of events is amazing. He suggests that the murderer can turn invisible and that Akechi himself is in fact the culprit. And the story is written so there’s a lot of evidence to support that. Edogawa was a very whimsical author. Of course, the truth turns out to be much duller, I,m guessing Ranpo didn’t want to turn his tales into surrealist comedies.
I think Pretty Boy Detective Club is a realization of all that whimsy and folly that Edogawa hinted at but ultimately held back from in his tales. And I really love it.
- Pretty Boy Detective Club ep1 – Upon a Star
- Pretty Boy Detective Club ep2 – Twinkle
- Pretty Boy Detective Club ep3 – New Rule
- Pretty Boy Detective Club ep4 – High Roller
- Pretty Boy Detective Club ep5 – Thin Air
- Pretty Boy Detective Club ep6 – Masterpiece
- Pretty Boy Detective Club ep7 – Constellation
- Pretty Boy Detective Club ep8 – Zashiki-warashi
- Pretty Boy Detective Club ep9 – Choir Contest
- Pretty Boy Detective Club ep10 – Ugly